The Whitney Reserve Apartments

Verified
This is a CoStar Verified® Listing

The Whitney Reserve in Madison, WI is verified by CoStar’s® proprietary screening and fraud detection process, so you can shop and rent with confidence on ApartmentHomeLiving.com. Always protect yourself when shopping online.

5201 Old Middleton Rd, Madison, WI 53705
(608) 413-4862
Check Availability

Photos

Contact

The Whitney Reserve

5201 Old Middleton Rd
Madison, WI 53705
(608) 413-4862
The Whitney Reserve in Madison, WI - Building Photo
  • Studio–2 Bedrooms
  • $1,550–$2,575Rent Pricing
  • 543–1,207Square Feet

About The Whitney Reserve

Welcome to The Whitney Reserve. Conveniently located at the stoplight corner of Whitney Way and Old Middleton Road, The Whitney Reserve provides immediate access to all the amenities on Madison’s west side. This upscale 49-unit apartment development has been meticulously integrated into the wooded Glen Oak Hills neighborhood. Step inside and a truly elevated lifestyle welcomes you with quality craftmanship and high-end finishes. At The Whitney Reserve you’re just blocks away from Madison’s premier open-air lifestyle district, Hilldale, which boasts iconic brands such as Apple, Target, AMC Theaters, Anthropologie, Peloton, lululemon, and more. Walk over to Shake Shack, bartaco, Muramoto Sushi, Forage Kitchen, Café Hollander, Crescendo Café, or the Great Dane Pub & Brewing Co. Specialty grocers Whole Foods and Metcalfe’s Market are just down the street, not to mention you’re only minutes from downtown, the University of Wisconsin campus, and the U.W. Hospital and Clinics. And just around the corner is the iconic Oakcrest Tavern. Live near the action, while enjoying the tranquility of The Whitney Reserve.

The Whitney Reserve is located in the Glen Oak Hills Neighborhood and 53705 Zip code of Madison, WI. This community is professionally managed by Flad Development & Investment

Property Contact Info

Floorplan Pricing and Availability

The Whitney Reserve offers Studio to 2 Bedroom apartments starting from $1,550 and having 543–1,207 sq ft. Here is the current pricing and availability:

  • Studio

    $1,550

    Studio

    Studio, 1 Bath, 543-557 sq ftAvailable Now

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq Ft
    $1,550Available NowStudio543-557 sq ft

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Cable Ready
    • Ceiling Fans
    • Framed Mirrors
    • Heating
    • Security System
    • Smoke Free
    • Sprinkler System
    • Storage Space
    • Tub/Shower
    • Washer/Dryer
    • Wheelchair Accessible (Rooms)

    Kitchen

    • Kitchen

    Model Rent and Fees

    Price

    • $1,550
  • 1 Bedroom

    From $1,795

    1-Bed

    1 Bed, 1 Bath, 715-786 sq ftAvailable Now

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq Ft
    From $1,795Available Now1-Bed715-786 sq ft

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Cable Ready
    • Ceiling Fans
    • Framed Mirrors
    • Heating
    • Security System
    • Smoke Free
    • Sprinkler System
    • Storage Space
    • Tub/Shower
    • Washer/Dryer
    • Wheelchair Accessible (Rooms)

    Kitchen

    • Kitchen

    Model Rent and Fees

    Price Range

    • $1,795 - $1,805
  • 2 Bedrooms

    From $2,095

    1-Bed + Den

    2 Beds, 1 Bath, 846-1071 sq ftAvailable Now

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq Ft
    From $2,095Available Now1-Bed + Den846-1071 sq ft

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Cable Ready
    • Ceiling Fans
    • Framed Mirrors
    • Heating
    • Security System
    • Smoke Free
    • Sprinkler System
    • Storage Space
    • Tub/Shower
    • Washer/Dryer
    • Wheelchair Accessible (Rooms)

    Kitchen

    • Kitchen

    Model Rent and Fees

    Price Range

    • $2,095 - $2,125

    From $2,395

    2-Bed

    2 Beds, 2 Baths, 1059-1207 sq ftAvailable Now

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq Ft
    From $2,395Available Now2-Bed1059-1207 sq ft

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Cable Ready
    • Ceiling Fans
    • Framed Mirrors
    • Heating
    • Security System
    • Smoke Free
    • Sprinkler System
    • Storage Space
    • Tub/Shower
    • Washer/Dryer
    • Wheelchair Accessible (Rooms)

    Kitchen

    • Kitchen

    Model Rent and Fees

    Price Range

    • $2,395 - $2,575
Price shown is base rent and may not include non-optional fees and utilities. View Fees and Policies for details. Price, availability, fees, and any applicable rent special are subject to change without notice.

Schedule a Tour

Schedule a Tour
Call us at: (608) 413-4862 to schedule a tour.

Property Information

Lease Terms

  • 12 months

Utilities Included

  • Trash Removal
  • Sewer
  • Water

Parking Fees & Info

Parking Garage

  • Garage Fee: $125 /Mo

Fee & Deposit Info

Recurring Fees

  • $125 Garage Fee

One-Time Fees

  • $50 Application Fee

3D Tours

Features and Amenities

On-Site Services

  • Car Charging Station
  • Recycling
  • Public Transportation
  • Key Fob Entry

Community Features

  • Multi Use Room
  • Elevator

Outdoor Features

  • Grill
  • Roof Terrace
  • Controlled Access

Recreation and Fitness

  • Fitness Center
  • Bicycle Storage

Interior Features

  • Storage Space
  • Security System
  • Heating
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Framed Mirrors
  • Tub/Shower
  • Sprinkler System
  • Cable Ready
  • Washer/Dryer
  • Air Conditioning
  • Wheelchair Accessible (Rooms)
  • Smoke Free

Kitchen Amenities

  • Kitchen

Unique Amenities

  • Garage Available
Google Map

Map

5201 Old Middleton Rd, Madison, WI 53705

Getting Around

Walk Score®

69 / 100

Somewhat Walkable

Some errands can be accomplished on foot

Bike Score®

90 / 100

Biker's Paradise

Daily errands can be accomplished on a bike

Transit Score®

42 / 100

Some Transit

A few nearby public transportation options

Frequently Asked Questions about The Whitney Reserve

Where is The Whitney Reserve located?

The Whitney Reserve is located at 5201 Old Middleton Rd near the Glen Oak Hills area of Madison, WI

What is the current rent range at The Whitney Reserve?

Studio to 2 Bedroom Apartments at The Whitney Reserve currently range from $1,550 to $2,575

Are pets allowed?

Call us today to find out our pet policy and if we allow pets

Lifestyle Ratings

  • Affordability Nice Value3.0

    The The Whitney Reserve Apartments are 8.8% more expensive than the average apartment in the Glen Oak Hills area, and 6.6% more expensive than the average apartment city-wide.

    Rent Comparison to the Glen Oak Hills Neighborhood

    FloorplanLowest Price HereNeighborhood Avg RentNbhd Avg RentCost Difference%
    Studio$1,550$1,420+$1309.2%
    1 Bedroom$1,795$1,599+$19612.3%
    2 Bedroom$2,095$1,998+$974.9%

    Rent Comparison to the city of Madison

    FloorplanLowest Price HereCity Average RentCost Difference%
    Studio$1,550$1,404+$14610.4%
    1 Bedroom$1,795$1,657+$1388.3%
    2 Bedroom$2,095$2,073+$221.1%

    Methodology: On 03/24/2025, ApartmentHomeLiving.com compared current rents by floorplan to 207 other apartment communities in the immediate area around The Whitney Reserve (Glen Oak Hills), and 2228 other apartment communities in Madison using today’s up-to-date pricing using the sum/count averaging formula. This data will be updated in real-time as prices fluctuate.

    Rent Pricing Data as of 03/24/2025

  • Eco-Friendly 3.4

    The Eco-Friendly Lifestyle score highlights how amenities and features at top local communities may support environmentally friendly, clean, and energy efficient living.

    Rating Factors

    This 3.4-star Eco-Friendly rating is based on the following features:

    • Car Charging Station(s)
    • Smoke Free Options
    • Recycling
    • Public Transportation
Learn more about Lifestyle Search

Renters Reviews and Ratings

4.0
0 Renters Reviews
ⓘ How is this Rating Determined?The property ratings on ApartmentHomeLiving.com are created using a 5-star scale that includes average renter review scores combined with building ratings to determine an overall blended property score.

Building ratings are based on a community’s features, including the building design, construction, exterior spaces, and amenities. To learn more about the CoStar Building Rating System, refer to our official guidelines here.

Nearby Schools

Crestwood Elementary

Madison Metropolitan
5930 Old Sauk Road
Public School - Grades PK-5 (272 Students)
In Attendance Zone2 minute drive / 0.7 miles away
4/10

Memorial High

Madison Metropolitan
201 South Gammon Road
Public School - Grades 9-12 (2025 Students)
In Attendance Zone5 minute drive / 1.8 miles away
6/10

Jefferson Middle

Madison Metropolitan
101 S Gammon Rd
Public School - Grades 6-8 (415 Students)
In Attendance Zone5 minute drive / 1.8 miles away
4/10
School data provided by GreatSchools.
details
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on scale of 1 (below average) and to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider needs as part of the school selection process.

About GreatSchools Data on ApartmentHomeLiving.com.

Points of Interest

Time and distance from The Whitney Reserve.

Arts Museums and Landmarks

227 State Street
8 minute drive / 4.12 miles away
201 State Street
8 minute drive / 4.14 miles away
2 East Main Street
9 minute drive / 4.4 miles away

Big Box and Retail

Walgreens
606 S Whitney Way
3 minute drive / 1.19 miles away
Jcpenney
23 W Towne Mall
5 minute drive / 1.96 miles away
Kohl's
7401 W Towne Way
4 minute drive / 2.28 miles away

Colleges and Universities

500 Lincoln Dr
4 minute drive / 2.1 miles away
1000 Edgewood College Drive
5 minute drive / 2.58 miles away
1701 Wright Street
16 minute drive / 7.63 miles away

Groceries

Whole Foods
4710 Madison Yards Way
1 minute drive / 0.66 miles away
Hy-Vee
2920 Fitchrona Rd
8 minute drive / 3.95 miles away
Festival Foods
660 Hometown Cir
12 minute drive / 5.72 miles away

Hospitals

600 Highland Avenue
4 minute drive / 2.13 miles away
202 S Park St
7 minute drive / 3.5 miles away
700 South Park St
7 minute drive / 3.58 miles away

Parks and Recreation

610 Walnut Street
4 minute drive / 2.3 miles away

The Whitney Reserve has 1 park within 2.3 miles, including Lakeshore Nature Preserve.

Shopping Centers

5003 University Ave
1 minute drive / 0.41 miles away
414-750 N Midvale Blvd
2 minute drive / 0.94 miles away
6102-6150 Mineral Point Rd
2 minute drive / 0.99 miles away

The Whitney Reserve has 5 shopping centers within 1.2 miles.

Nearby Neighborhoods

Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $625
View Rentals
Studio to 4 Bedroom Apartments from $625
View Rentals
Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $646
View Rentals

Rental Price Ranges in the Area

BedroomAverage RentCheapest RentHighest Rent
Madison Studio Apartments $1,404$695$3,890
Madison 1 Bedroom Apartments $1,657$565$4,965
Madison 2 Bedroom Apartments $2,073$747$7,000
Madison 3 Bedroom Apartments $2,430$730$6,105
Madison 4 Bedroom Apartments $1,909$902$4,900
Madison 5 Bedroom Apartments $1,635$862$7,277

Browse Top Apartments in Madison

By Price

By Community Type

By Amenities

Viewing: The Whitney Reserve | Desktop Version | Listing Updated: 03/22/2025 | AHLGLD