173 Bay St

Sag Harbor, NY 11963
(631) 919-7998
Check Availability

Photos

Contact

173 Bay St

173 Bay St
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
(631) 919-7998
173 Bay St in Sag Harbor, NY - Building Photo
5 Bedroom - Home for Rent
  • 5BR, 6BAHome
  • -$1Price
  • Available NowAvailability

About 173 Bay St

5,500+- sf New 5 bedroom, 5 1/2 bath A modern perspective on a classic Sag Harbor home home is set on shy 1/2 acre in the heart of Sag Harbor Village. Manicured lawn and hedges provide a serene lifestyle with covered porches, patios, outdoor living and dining with fireplace inside and out, gunite heated pool and designer finishes throughout. Conveniently located adjacent to village reserve bordering Havens Beach and 3 blocks to the marina, Main Street's shops, restaurants and Jitney. A bright open chef's kitchen overlooks the lush backyard and sun drenched pool. The quartz island with counter seating opens to a chic relaxed great room. A first floor ensuite guest bedroom, Office/study and living room with oversized fireplace and French doors introducing the outdoor covered bluestone porch for additional entertaining. The second floor offers three en-suite bedrooms plus the primary bedroom suite that has an attached study and balcony. Other amenities include, a gym, study, office, mud room and laundry room and home theater.

173 Bay St is located in the Outlying Eastern Suffolk Neighborhood and 11963 Zip code of Sag Harbor, NY.

Property Contact Info

Contact: Jason Schommer

Features and Amenities

On-Site Services

  • Package Service
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Garden Style

Outdoor Features

  • Controlled Access

Interior Features

  • Air Conditioning

Pet Policy

  • No Pets Allowed
Google Map

Map

173 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Frequently Asked Questions about 173 Bay St

Where is 173 Bay St located?

173 Bay St is located at 173 Bay St near the Outlying Eastern Suffolk area of Sag Harbor, NY

What is the current rent range at 173 Bay St?

Call us today for rates on the 5 Bedroom option at 173 Bay St

Are pets allowed?

Call us today to find out our pet policy and if we allow pets

Nearby Schools

Sag Harbor Elementary School

Sag Harbor Union Free
68 Hampton Street
Public School - Grades PK-5 (426 Students)
In Attendance Zone1 minute drive / 0.3 miles away
5/10

Pierson Middle High School

Sag Harbor Union Free
200 Jermain Avenue
Public School - Grades 6-12 (525 Students)
In Attendance Zone1 minute drive / 0.4 miles away
5/10
School data provided by GreatSchools.
details
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on scale of 1 (below average) and to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider needs as part of the school selection process.

About GreatSchools Data on ApartmentHomeLiving.com.

Points of Interest

Time and distance from 173 Bay St.

Big Box and Retail

Sleepy's
71 Montauk Hwy
10 minute drive / 4.89 miles away

Groceries

Iga
48 Main St
2 minute drive / 0.82 miles away
Stop & Shop
67 Newtown Ln
11 minute drive / 5.42 miles away

Hospitals

201 Manor Place
18 minute drive / 8.76 miles away

Shopping Centers

352-354 Montauk Hwy
8 minute drive / 3.96 miles away
2488 Montauk Hwy
9 minute drive / 4.46 miles away
2004-2104 Montauk Hwy
10 minute drive / 4.89 miles away

173 Bay St has 5 shopping centers within 7.2 miles.

Transit Stations

9 minute drive / 4.47 miles away
10 minute drive / 5.12 miles away
16 minute drive / 7.81 miles away

Nearby Neighborhoods

Studio to 7 Bedroom Apartments from $1,600
View Rentals
Studio to 7 Bedroom Apartments from $350
View Rentals

Rental Price Ranges in the Area

BedroomAverage RentCheapest RentHighest Rent
Sag Harbor Studio Apartments $1,561$1,150$3,127
Sag Harbor 1 Bedroom Apartments $2,149$905$10,000+
Sag Harbor 2 Bedroom Apartments $3,336$1,100$10,000+
Sag Harbor 3 Bedroom Apartments $26,944$1,905$10,000+
Sag Harbor 4 Bedroom Apartments $58,274$10,000$10,000+

Browse Top Apartments in Sag Harbor

By Price

By Community Type

By Amenities

Viewing: 173 Bay St | Desktop Version | Listing Updated: 04/21/2025