Setauket, New York Neighborhoods and Nearby Cities

Setauket, NY Neighborhoods

OF

Old Field

4.0 stars
Outdoors
$2,300
3 Rentals

Other Neighborhoods near Setauket, NY

AP

Argyle Park

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,300 to $4,250
58 Rentals
A

Arista

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,850 to $9,020
46 Rentals
A

Asharoken

$2,100 to $3,470
3 Rentals
B

Baywood

3.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,601 to $3,495
10 Rentals
BT

Belle Terre

$2,999
1 Rentals
BG

Birchwood Glen

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,500 to $5,375
125 Rentals
Black Rock

Black Rock

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$650 to $80,000
288 Rentals
BA

Boston Ave Mill Hill

3.5 stars
Affordability
$1,025 to $3,800
44 Rentals
BA

Boston Avenue

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,025 to $3,800
114 Rentals
Bridgeport South End

Bridgeport South End

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $3,980
125 Rentals
Bridgeport West End

Bridgeport West End

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $6,996
221 Rentals
BF

Brightwaters Farm

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,550 to $9,978
163 Rentals
BR

Broad River

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,100 to $5,409
118 Rentals
B

Brooklawn

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $6,996
196 Rentals
BS

Brooklawn St Vincent

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $4,700
179 Rentals
B

Brookside

3.5 stars
Affordability
$1,400 to $5,409
74 Rentals
BD

Business District

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,300 to $4,250
83 Rentals
C

Caledonia

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,850 to $9,020
60 Rentals
CS

Candy Section

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,780 to $5,900
38 Rentals
CF

Central Fire Island

$18,000 to $32,000
4 Rentals
Central Norwalk

Central Norwalk

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,200 to $5,409
138 Rentals
CS

Central Suffolk

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$823 to $32,000
499 Rentals
CN

Commack North

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,780 to $5,900
51 Rentals
CH

Compo–Owenoke Historic District

$2,000 to $2,250
3 Rentals
CB

Copper Beech Village

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,500 to $5,148
56 Rentals
CC

Courthouse Commons

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,500 to $7,172
114 Rentals
CC

Crescent Cove

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,750 to $4,300
22 Rentals
DR

Deer Run

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,995 to $3,475
44 Rentals
Devon Walnut Beach

Devon Walnut Beach

3.5 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,795 to $3,595
22 Rentals
DB

Downtown Bay Shore

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,550 to $9,978
96 Rentals
DB

Downtown Bethpage

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,011 to $23,606
43 Rentals
Downtown Bridgeport

Downtown Bridgeport

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $3,951
64 Rentals
Downtown Harbor Post Road South

Downtown Harbor Post Road South

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,250 to $9,731
38 Rentals
Downtown Milford

Downtown Milford

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,250 to $9,731
47 Rentals
Downtown Norwalk

Downtown Norwalk

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,100 to $5,409
129 Rentals
EE

East End

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $3,300
91 Rentals
EF

East Farmingdale

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,900 to $23,606
23 Rentals
East Massapequa

East Massapequa

3.5 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,700 to $5,949
26 Rentals
EN

East Norwalk

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,376
202 Rentals
East Patchogue

East Patchogue

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,200 to $5,148
33 Rentals
ES

East Shoreham

$2,500 to $2,800
3 Rentals
East Side Bridgeport

East Side Bridgeport

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,050 to $3,951
120 Rentals
EF

Eastern Fire Island

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,200 to $5,148
63 Rentals
EN

Eatons Neck

$2,880 to $3,470
2 Rentals
E

Elwood

$2,000 to $2,800
7 Rentals
EZ

Enterprise Zone

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $3,500
249 Rentals
FH

Fairfield Historic District

$3,500
1 Rentals
FC

Five Corners

$1,650 to $8,534
19 Rentals
FH

Fort Hill

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$2,300 to $7,000
40 Rentals
FS

Fort Salonga

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,800 to $4,650
50 Rentals
FS

Fred Shores

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,300 to $5,453
119 Rentals
GH

Golden Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,376
112 Rentals
GH

Gordon Heights

3.5 stars
Cost Per Square Foot
$3,600
2 Rentals
GF

Greens Farms

$2,014 to $5,868
9 Rentals
H

Halesite

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$2,520 to $6,061
10 Rentals
H

Harborview

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,113
125 Rentals
HO

Head of the Harbor

$2,075 to $3,175
5 Rentals
HH

Hospital Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,200 to $5,376
116 Rentals
HV

Huntington Village

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$2,100 to $9,020
73 Rentals
IT

Islip Terrace

4.0 stars
Cost Per Square Foot
$1,850 to $3,500
21 Rentals
LR

Lake Ronkonkoma

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,650 to $8,534
62 Rentals
Lake Ronkonkoma

Lake Ronkonkoma

3.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,650 to $8,534
33 Rentals
LW

Lakeview Woods

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,500 to $5,148
156 Rentals
LH

Laurel Hollow

$500
2 Rentals
Lower East End

Lower East End

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $3,300
102 Rentals
M

Madison

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $3,500
120 Rentals
MB

Marvin Beach

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,409
198 Rentals
M

Mayfair

3.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,950 to $3,865
8 Rentals
M

Merritt

$1,832 to $5,409
19 Rentals
MH

Mill Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$800 to $3,800
186 Rentals
MA

Myrtle Avenue Historic District

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,495 to $5,868
93 Rentals
N

Nissequogue

$2,600
3 Rentals
North Amityville

North Amityville

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,850 to $6,024
28 Rentals
NB

North Bay Shore

$1,650 to $3,245
10 Rentals
North Bellport

North Bellport

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,367 to $3,999
10 Rentals
North Bridgeport

North Bridgeport

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,025 to $3,500
63 Rentals
ND

North Deer Park

3.5 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,601 to $3,600
23 Rentals
North End

North End

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $5,968
174 Rentals
NG

North Great River

4.0 stars
Cost Per Square Foot
$1,850 to $3,475
14 Rentals
NG

North Great River

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,850 to $3,475
13 Rentals
NL

North Lindenhurst

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,700 to $6,024
26 Rentals
NM

North Massapequa

$3,200
2 Rentals
NP

North Patchogue

3.5 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,880 to $4,250
12 Rentals
NS

North Smithtown

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,780 to $4,139
13 Rentals
NC

Norwalk Center

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,200 to $5,409
127 Rentals
OH

Oak Hills

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,376
189 Rentals
OH

Old Hill

$500
5 Rentals
PG

Paradise Green

4.0 stars
Affordability
$800 to $5,378
127 Rentals
PM

Pecks Mill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,025 to $9,731
146 Rentals
P

Plainedge

$1,650
1 Rentals
PR

Poospatuck Reservation

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$2,055 to $5,334
6 Rentals
PS

Presidential Section

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,300 to $4,250
87 Rentals
R

Reservoir

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $5,968
219 Rentals
RW

Reservoir Whiskey Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $5,968
77 Rentals
R

Rowayton

3.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $11,755
77 Rentals
S

Saugatuck

$2,000 to $3,025
10 Rentals
SE

Setauket East Setauket

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,800 to $6,163
55 Rentals
S

Silvermine

$1,832 to $5,003
17 Rentals
SoNo

SoNo

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,409
116 Rentals
SE

South End

3.5 stars
Affordability
$770 to $3,300
76 Rentals
SF

South Farmingdale

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$2,000 to $23,606
26 Rentals
SH

South Huntington

$1,850 to $2,850
14 Rentals
SS

South Stratford

4.0 stars
Affordability
$800 to $3,800
130 Rentals
S

Southdown

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$2,300 to $7,000
56 Rentals
SS

Southwestern Suffolk

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,139 to $32,000
451 Rentals
SH

Spring Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,376
204 Rentals
SJ

St James

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,950 to $4,139
11 Rentals
SV

Stratfield Village

3.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $6,996
34 Rentals
SC

Stratford Center Historic District

4.0 stars
Affordability
$800 to $3,800
127 Rentals
SH

Strawberry Hill

3.5 stars
Affordability
$1,495 to $5,409
63 Rentals
S

Summerfield

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$823 to $5,375
125 Rentals
T

Terryville

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,558 to $6,885
35 Rentals
TC

The Colony

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,500 to $8,534
137 Rentals
TG

The Green

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,200 to $5,409
101 Rentals
TH

The Hollow

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $3,951
137 Rentals
TV

The Villages at Mount Sinai Park

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,550 to $6,885
50 Rentals
Upper Madison

Upper Madison

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $5,968
269 Rentals
V

Vanderbilt

3.0 stars
Affordability
$1,780 to $5,900
23 Rentals
VH

VIllage Hill

3.5 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,780 to $5,900
27 Rentals
VO

Village of the Branch

$2,165 to $2,515
2 Rentals
WB

West Bay Shore

3.5 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,610 to $3,500
39 Rentals
WE

West End West Side

4.0 stars
Affordability
$650 to $3,951
202 Rentals
WH

West Hampton Dunes

$28,000
1 Rentals
WH

West Hills

$2,100 to $3,100
22 Rentals
WM

West Main

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,100 to $5,409
80 Rentals
West Norwalk

West Norwalk

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $5,376
152 Rentals
WR

West Rocks

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,100 to $5,409
73 Rentals
WS

West Side

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,139 to $3,600
60 Rentals
WS

Western Suffolk

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,011 to $23,606
605 Rentals
WH

Wheatley Heights

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,800 to $4,795
14 Rentals
WH

Whiskey Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
$450 to $5,968
289 Rentals
WP

Wilson Point

3.5 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $11,755
77 Rentals
Wolfpit

Wolfpit

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,100 to $5,409
139 Rentals
W

Woodmont

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,250 to $9,731
29 Rentals
WP

Woods Pond

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,100 to $5,409
98 Rentals
W

Woodward

4.0 stars
Affordability
$1,000 to $11,755
127 Rentals
WA

Woodward Avenue

$1,000
4 Rentals
W

Wyandanch

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
$1,139 to $4,795
17 Rentals

Expert Rental Resources

Helpful Apartment Articles, How-To's and Tips

The rental experts at ApartmentHomeLiving.com provide you with top advice, tools, and tips for understanding the leasing process and finding the perfect rental. Here are a few helpful rental and leasing articles from our experts to guide you on your search.

decorative image for Battling the Butts: Your Guide to the Reality of Smoke-Free Renting article

Battling the Butts: Your Guide to the Reality of Smoke-Free Renting

Written by: Andrea Lee Negroni, JD

While many apartment buildings are “no smoking” properties, it’s hard to know exactly how many. In 2017, the National Apartment Association reported more than half of rental properties had smoke free policies.

decorative image for Understanding Amenity Fees: Know Where You Might Be Able to Save Money article

Understanding Amenity Fees: Know Where You Might Be Able to Save Money

Written by: Amber Kanuckel

With the rising costs of housing, a lot of renters are asking this question: Is it possible to opt out of various amenities that your rental property offers so that you can avoid paying the fees.

decorative image for How Your Move-In Inspection Can Protect Your Security Deposit  article

How Your Move-In Inspection Can Protect Your Security Deposit

Written by: Christine Leonard, Esq.

If you’re anything like most people, housing costs represent a huge chunk of your monthly budget. On top of that, moving can be both a stressful and expensive affair.

decorative image for Signing Your Apartment Lease: The Basics article

Signing Your Apartment Lease: The Basics

Written by: Trey Huguley

When you're about to sign a lease for the first time, it can feel a bit overwhelming. You don’t want to miss any important details hidden in the fine print.