3 Bedroom Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island, NY (53 Rentals)

How Many Bedrooms?Done
Select your price rangeDone
Lifestyle Matching SearchDone
Learn more about Lifestyle Search
By AmenitiesDone
By Community TypeDone
Features and AvailabilityDone
Done
property at 6 Crab Creek Rd

6 Crab Creek Rd

Shelter IslandNY11964
property at 11 Tims Trail

11 Tims Trail

Shelter IslandNY11964
property at 9 Country Club Dr

9 Country Club Dr

Shelter IslandNY11964

Navigating the Rental Market: Tips for First-Time Renters

Entering the rental market? Learn these simple tips and strategies to avoid common pitfalls and make confident choices. Rent with peace of mind.

Read Article
property at 5 Penny's Path

5 Penny's Path

Shelter IslandNY11964

Know Your Rights - How Discrimination Laws Impact Landlords and Tenants

Read our practical guide to landlord and tenant rights. Understand protected classes, reasonable accommodations, and legal exceptions to prevent housing discrimination.

Read Article
property at 21 Peconic Ave

21 Peconic Ave

Shelter IslandNY11964
property at 15 Terry Dr

15 Terry Dr

Sag HarborNY11963
property at 308 Wiggins St

308 Wiggins St

GreenportNY11944
Showing Results 1-50, Page 1 of 2

Shelter Island, NY Local Guide

Largest Available Shelter Island and Nearby 3 Bedroom Apartments

The largest available 3 Bedroom apartment unit in Shelter Island, NY is found at The Edgewater in the South Lyme neighborhood and is 2,156 square feet priced from $3,395. The Cove at Gateway Commons in the Southwest New London Lyme neighborhood has the second largest 3 Bedroom, which is sized at 1,960 square feet and currently listed start at $3,795. Here is today’s list of the largest available 3 Bedroom units in Shelter Island:

Apartment ListingModel NameSquare FootagePriced From
The EdgewaterParker2,156 Sq Ft$3,395
The Cove at Gateway CommonsAnchor Townhome1,960 Sq Ft$3,795
The Sound at Gateway CommonsThe Madison1,320 Sq Ft$2,895

Cheapest Available Shelter Island and Nearby 3 Bedroom Apartments

As of May 03, 2025 the lowest priced 3 Bedroom apartment unit in Shelter Island, NY is the The Madison Model starting from $2,895 at The Sound at Gateway Commons in the Southwest New London Lyme neighborhood. The second most affordable Shelter Island 3 Bedroom is the Parker Model at The Edgewater starting at $3,395 in the South Lyme neighborhood. The average price for all 3 Bedroom apartments in Shelter Island is currently $25,561. Here is today’s list of the cheapest available 3 Bedroom options in Shelter Island:

Apartment ListingModel NamePriced From
The Sound at Gateway CommonsThe Madison$2,895
The EdgewaterParker$3,395
The Cove at Gateway CommonsAnchor Townhome$3,795

Quick Rent Budget Calculator

How much rent can you afford?

The common "Rule of Thumb" is that rent should be no more than 30% of your income. How much is that? Enter your monthly income and click "Calculate My Budget" to find out.

decorative image of people with a giant lease agreement

Remember the 3 Rules of Real Estate:
Location, Location, Location!

Explore Shelter Island, NY Rentals by Map

Decorative image of map

See the most popular apartments and homes in Shelter Island, NY

View MapShelter Island, NY Apartments MapView MapShelter Island, NY Rental Homes Map

Getting Around Shelter Island, NY

Walk Score®

24 / 100

Car-Dependent

Almost all errands require a car

Bike Score®

32 / 100

Somewhat Bikeable

Minimal bike infrastructure

What Are Walk Score®, Transit Score®, and Bike Score® Ratings?

  • Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address.
  • Transit Score® measures access to public transit.
  • Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.

Frequently Asked Questions about 3 Bedroom Shelter Island Apartments

What is the Cheapest apartment in Shelter Island with 3 Bedroom?

Currently the most affordable 3 Bedroom in Shelter Island is at The Sound at Gateway Commons listed at $2,895.

How much is the average rent for a 3 Bedroom Shelter Island Apartment?

The average rent for a 3 Bedroom Apartment in Shelter Island is $25,561.

What is the largest available 3 Bedroom Shelter Island Apartment for rent?

Today's apartment with the most square footage in Shelter Island is a 2,156 square feet unit starting from $3,395 at The Edgewater.

What is the average size for Shelter Island 3 Bedroom Apartments for rent?

The average size for a 3 Bedroom rental in Shelter Island is currently 1,875 sq ft.

Expert Rental Resources

Helpful Apartment Articles, How-To's and Tips

The rental experts at ApartmentHomeLiving.com provide you with top advice, tools, and tips for understanding the leasing process and finding the perfect rental. Here are a few helpful rental and leasing articles from our experts to guide you on your search.

decorative image for Navigating the Rental Market: Tips for First-Time Renters article

Navigating the Rental Market: Tips for First-Time Renters

Written by: Sandy Baker

Making the decision to rent is exciting and terrifying at the same time. For many people, there are a lot of unknowns.

decorative image for Rise of Digital Nomads: Remote Work Tips for Apartment Renters article

Rise of Digital Nomads: Remote Work Tips for Apartment Renters

Written by: Brandie Parton

As a digital nomad, you no longer call a set address or office building your home for eight hours of the day or more.

decorative image for Know Your Rights - How Discrimination Laws Impact Landlords and Tenants article

Know Your Rights - How Discrimination Laws Impact Landlords and Tenants

Written by: Christine Leonard, Esq.

Everyone needs a place to live and to call home. For decades, the federal government has established protections to ensure that individuals and families can find housing free from discriminatory barriers.

decorative image for Renting Smart: Lease Basics Every Renter Needs article

Renting Smart: Lease Basics Every Renter Needs

Written by: Christine Leonard, Esq.

Often, in the excitement of finding a new place to live, there’s a rush to make it happen, and - too often - a new tenant signs a lease without reading it carefully.